Aesthetic Realism Foundation

  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Directions
  • To Contribute
  • flat_facebook

Blog

“What the Self Is—Including One’s Own”—The Right of Aesthetic Realism to Be Known #2057

May 12, 2021

Steven Weiner, Computer Specialist and Aesthetic Realism associate, writes:

Each one of us has a self, but a most important question is: how much do we understand that self? What is it we most need to know about our very selves, and the selves of other people? For the explanation that really makes sense and will enable you to understand the self which is yours, and that of others, read “What the Self Is–Including One’s Own,” the much needed, compelling new issue of The Right of Aesthetic Realism to Be Known!

The commentary by Ellen Reiss begins:

Dear Unknown Friends:

We begin to serialize here The Renaissance Shows Self, a 1970 lecture by Eli Siegel. With all that America is in the midst of right now, there is this—which is historic and beautiful: a growing insistence that every person be seen as having a self that is as real and full as anyone else’s. In the lecture we’re serializing, Mr. Siegel uses English Renaissance poems to speak about the self that is everyone’s. And as introduction, I’ll say some things about the way Aesthetic Realism sees the self, a way that is different from other approaches and is great and true.

We need Aesthetic Realism’s explanation of the self in order to know our own selves, be ourselves, be true to ourselves. We also need it in order for people to see other people with real justice. As I speak about Eli Siegel’s historic understanding of the self, I’ll quote some passages from his writing on the subject, passages beautiful as prose and comprehension. And I’m sure that in the course of this serialization, I’ll quote others.

The Constant Situation

In the very title of Eli Siegel’s book Self and World: An Explanation of Aesthetic Realism, is to be found the big, constant situation of every self. We each have to do centrally with nothing less than the world, the whole world. He wrote:

We all of us start with a here, ever so snug and ever so immediate. And this here is surrounded strangely, endlessly, by a there. We are always meeting this there: in other words, we are always meeting what is not ourselves, and we have to do something about it. We have to be ourselves, and give to this great and diversified there, which is not ourselves, what it deserves. [Self and World, p. 91]

There is nothing in the world, Mr. Siegel showed, that is disconnected from the self of each of us. We are the results of history, of evolution; the atomic structure, present in all things of matter, is intimate to us—we could not be without it. The language we use to speak with, and think privately to ourselves with, was created over centuries by millions of people we never met. If we hear a thing mentioned, even something we never heard of before, it’s now in our mind in some fashion—and our mind always had the possibility of containing it. In chapter 9 of Self and World, “The Child,” Mr. Siegel writes:

The first purpose of a self is to be. It therefore has to be asked: What does it mean for a self to be?…A baby at birth is pushing towards freedom and inclusiveness of perception. By this I mean that a baby wants to feel that it is; and at the same time, wants to feel all that is besides its own life. [P. 238]

Our learning about this is the beginning of justice not only to our own selves but to all people. A person of any background or skin tone is a self, richly individual yet born into and having to do with everything. When you see a person this way you cannot be brutal to him or her….Read more

Most Viewed Posts

  • The Philosophy of Depression

  • The Right of Aesthetic Realism to Be Known

  • “Alexander Calder: Art Answers the Questions of Our Lives”

  • Black & White: A Poem with Photographs

  • “Is Beauty the Making One of Opposites?”

  • “Books”—an Essay for Children

  • “A Good Husband: What Does That Mean?”

  • “Man and Nature in New York and Kansas”

  • “Hawthorne’s ‘The Man of Adamant’”

  • “The Beauty of Art & the Pain about Love”

  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Mission Statement
    • What Is Aesthetic Realism?
    • Eli Siegel, Founder
    • Faculty
    • Some Background
  • Calendar
  • How to Study
    Aesthetic Realism
    • Classes
      • The Aesthetic Realism Explanation of Poetry
      • Anthropology Is about You & Everyone
      • “If It Moves, It Can Move You”: Opposites in the Cinema
      • The Visual Arts & the Opposites
      • The Aesthetic Realism Teaching Method
      • The Opposites in Music
      • Understanding Marriage!
    • Consultations
      • What Happens in an Aesthetic Realism Consultation?
      • Aesthetic Realism Consultation of Nancy Huntting
      • Coldness, Warmth, & Mistakes by Jaime Torres, DPM
      • What Kind of Effect on Men? by Lauren Phillips
      • My Aesthetic Realism Consultations by Richita Anderson
      • The Fight about Excitement by Dan McClung
      • The Trouble with Competition by Miriam Weiss
    • Workshops for Educators
    • Outreach
      • Art Talks
      • Architecture
      • Bullying
      • Film Presentations
      • Seniors
      • Theatre Company
      • Young People
  • Events
    • Public Seminars
    • Theatrical & Musical Matinees
    • Saturday Night Presentations
    • Directions
  • Periodical
  • Library
    • Online Library
    • Films & Videos
    • Blog
    • Lectures
      • Aesthetic Realism and Love, Introduction
      • Aesthetic Realism and Love, Part 1
      • Aesthetic Realism and Love, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Expression, Introduction by Ellen Reiss
      • Aesthetic Realism and Expression, Part 1
      • Aesthetic Realism and Expression, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Hope
      • Aesthetic Realism and Hope, Part 2
      • The Drama of Mind, Introduction
      • The Drama of Mind, Part 1
      • The Drama of Mind, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Introduction
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Part 1
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Part 3
      • Map to Happiness, by Eli Siegel
      • Greenwich Village Is in the World
      • Mind and Intelligence, Introduction by Ellen Reiss
      • Mind and Intelligence, by Eli Siegel, Part 1
      • Mind and Intelligence, by Eli Siegel, Part 2
      • Mind and Intelligence, by Eli Siegel, Part 3
      • Mind and Schools
      • Mind and Schools by Eli Siegel, Part 1
      • Mind and Schools by Eli Siegel, Part 2
      • Mind and Schools by Eli Siegel, Part 3
      • Aesthetic Realism and People
      • Aesthetic Realism and Education
      • So, What Is Bitterness?
    • News Archive
    • Related Resources
  • Book Store
  • Visual & Dramatic Arts
    • Terrain Gallery
    • Koppelman Foundation
    • Aesthetic Realism Theatre Company
  • En Español

To Contribute | Contact | En Español

Aesthetic Realism Foundation    141 Greene Street   New York, NY 10012   212.777.4490

Privacy Policy | Blog Comment Policy   Copyright © 1997–2025   Aesthetic Realism Foundation

To Contribute | Contact | En Español

Aesthetic Realism Foundation
141 Greene Street
New York, NY 10012
212.777.4490

Privacy Policy

Blog Comment Policy

Copyright © 1997–2025
Aesthetic Realism Foundation

MENU
  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Mission Statement
    • What Is Aesthetic Realism?
    • Eli Siegel, Founder
    • Faculty
    • Some Background
  • Calendar
  • How to Study
    Aesthetic Realism
    • Classes
    • Consultations
    • Workshops for Educators
    • Outreach
  • Events
    • Public Seminars
    • Theatrical & Musical Matinees
    • Saturday Night Presentations
    • Directions
  • Periodical
  • Library
    • Online Library
    • Films & Videos
    • Blog
    • Lectures
    • News Archive
    • Related Resources
  • Book Store
  • Visual & Dramatic Arts
    • Terrain Gallery
    • Koppelman Foundation
    • Aesthetic Realism Theatre Company
  • En Español
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
    • Directions
    • To Contribute
    • flat_facebook