Aesthetic Realism Foundation

  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Directions
  • To Contribute
  • flat_facebook

Blog

“We—& Children—Are Philosophic”—The Right of Aesthetic Realism to Be Known #1892

January 14, 2015

Michael Palmer, Aesthetic Realism associate Michael Palmer, sportswriter and Aesthetic Realism associate, writes:

We all want to be wider, more generous, happier, but how can we be, and what is it that stops us? Read “We—& Children—Are Philosophic,” the kind, culturally rich new issue of The Right of Aesthetic Realism to Be Known. The commentary by Ellen Reiss begins:

Dear Unknown Friends:

We are serializing the magnificent 1965 lecture Philosophy Consists of Instincts, by Eli Siegel. And we include here too part of a paper by Aesthetic Realism consultant Nancy Huntting, from a recent seminar titled “How Can Selfishness & Generosity Make Sense in a Woman’s Life?”

In his lecture Mr. Siegel shows that the big battle going on in people’s lives every day is also the continuous conflict in a field that seems so different: the history of philosophy. This conflict is about fact and a notion of value, and it takes many forms in both philosophy and us. Centrally, it takes the form in us of the desire to see, to know, versus the desire to have things make us comfortable and important.

Reality: Definite & Illimitable

In the present section of his lecture, Mr. Siegel speaks about two opposites in thought: reality as definite, immediate, the objects right before one; and reality as indefinitely wide, expansive—as illimitable. In each of these opposites, the fight he has been describing is present: we can use each in behalf either of knowing or of making ourselves contemptuously comfortable. I am going to comment on them briefly in relation to a poem by Robert Louis Stevenson from A Child’s Garden of Verses, because this Aesthetic Realism principle is true about people of every age: “The world, art, and self explain each other: each is the aesthetic oneness of opposites.” I love Eli Siegel’s seeing that the questions of children are philosophic all the way. And I love his showing that, at any age, the big interference with our lives, the corrupter of the philosophic opposites in us, is contempt: our desire “to be for ourselves by making less of the outside world.”

A boy of 5 wants to see widely. He’d like to say “Ooh!,” see mystery in things, feel there’s meaning he can’t run. Yet the same boy, Jonah, can also get mad if he meets something he doesn’t understand: he’d like to feel he’s in a world he can limit and manage. On the other hand, he can also use the “wide” contemptuously: he can like going into a world far away from the people he knows; he can close his eyes and get rid of everything, or be somewhere apart in his mind when people are talking. “Where are you, Jonah?” his mother asked last night at dinner, when he was right across the table from her.

“Foreign Lands”

In many of Stevenson’s poems, a child is going after one (or both) of those two things, the expansive or the definite—sometimes with respect, sometimes with contempt. The very fine poem “Foreign Lands” begins:

Up into the cherry tree
Who should climb but little me?
I held the trunk with both my hands
And looked abroad on foreign lands.

 Read more

Most Viewed Posts

  • The Philosophy of Depression

  • The Right of Aesthetic Realism to Be Known

  • “Alexander Calder: Art Answers the Questions of Our Lives”

  • Black & White: A Poem with Photographs

  • “Is Beauty the Making One of Opposites?”

  • “Books”—an Essay for Children

  • “A Good Husband: What Does That Mean?”

  • “Man and Nature in New York and Kansas”

  • “Hawthorne’s ‘The Man of Adamant’”

  • “The Beauty of Art & the Pain about Love”

  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Mission Statement
    • What Is Aesthetic Realism?
    • Eli Siegel, Founder
    • Faculty
    • Some Background
  • Calendar
  • How to Study
    Aesthetic Realism
    • Classes
      • The Aesthetic Realism Explanation of Poetry
      • Anthropology Is about You & Everyone
      • “If It Moves, It Can Move You”: Opposites in the Cinema
      • The Visual Arts & the Opposites
      • The Aesthetic Realism Teaching Method
      • The Opposites in Music
      • Understanding Marriage!
    • Consultations
      • What Happens in an Aesthetic Realism Consultation?
      • Aesthetic Realism Consultation of Nancy Huntting
      • Coldness, Warmth, & Mistakes by Jaime Torres, DPM
      • What Kind of Effect on Men? by Lauren Phillips
      • My Aesthetic Realism Consultations by Richita Anderson
      • The Fight about Excitement by Dan McClung
      • The Trouble with Competition by Miriam Weiss
    • Workshops for Educators
    • Outreach
      • Art Talks
      • Architecture
      • Bullying
      • Film Presentations
      • Seniors
      • Theatre Company
      • Young People
  • Events
    • Public Seminars
    • Theatrical & Musical Matinees
    • Saturday Night Presentations
    • Directions
  • Periodical
  • Library
    • Online Library
    • Films & Videos
    • Blog
    • Lectures
      • Aesthetic Realism and Love, Introduction
      • Aesthetic Realism and Love, Part 1
      • Aesthetic Realism and Love, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Expression, Introduction by Ellen Reiss
      • Aesthetic Realism and Expression, Part 1
      • Aesthetic Realism and Expression, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Hope
      • Aesthetic Realism and Hope, Part 2
      • The Drama of Mind, Introduction
      • The Drama of Mind, Part 1
      • The Drama of Mind, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Introduction
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Part 1
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Part 3
      • Map to Happiness, by Eli Siegel
      • Greenwich Village Is in the World
      • Mind and Intelligence, Introduction by Ellen Reiss
      • Mind and Intelligence, by Eli Siegel, Part 1
      • Mind and Intelligence, by Eli Siegel, Part 2
      • Mind and Intelligence, by Eli Siegel, Part 3
      • Mind and Schools
      • Mind and Schools by Eli Siegel, Part 1
      • Mind and Schools by Eli Siegel, Part 2
      • Mind and Schools by Eli Siegel, Part 3
      • Aesthetic Realism and People
      • Aesthetic Realism and Education
      • So, What Is Bitterness?
    • News Archive
    • Related Resources
  • Book Store
  • Visual & Dramatic Arts
    • Terrain Gallery
    • Koppelman Foundation
    • Aesthetic Realism Theatre Company
  • En Español

To Contribute | Contact | En Español

Aesthetic Realism Foundation    141 Greene Street   New York, NY 10012   212.777.4490

Privacy Policy | Blog Comment Policy   Copyright © 1997–2025   Aesthetic Realism Foundation

To Contribute | Contact | En Español

Aesthetic Realism Foundation
141 Greene Street
New York, NY 10012
212.777.4490

Privacy Policy

Blog Comment Policy

Copyright © 1997–2025
Aesthetic Realism Foundation

MENU
  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Mission Statement
    • What Is Aesthetic Realism?
    • Eli Siegel, Founder
    • Faculty
    • Some Background
  • Calendar
  • How to Study
    Aesthetic Realism
    • Classes
    • Consultations
    • Workshops for Educators
    • Outreach
  • Events
    • Public Seminars
    • Theatrical & Musical Matinees
    • Saturday Night Presentations
    • Directions
  • Periodical
  • Library
    • Online Library
    • Films & Videos
    • Blog
    • Lectures
    • News Archive
    • Related Resources
  • Book Store
  • Visual & Dramatic Arts
    • Terrain Gallery
    • Koppelman Foundation
    • Aesthetic Realism Theatre Company
  • En Español
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
    • Directions
    • To Contribute
    • flat_facebook