Aesthetic Realism Foundation

  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Directions
  • To Contribute
  • flat_facebook

Blog

“Is It Me, Darling, or Somebody Else, God Knows Who?—A Love Poem”

July 10, 2024

Carol McCluer, singer and actor with the Aesthetic Realism Theatre Company, writes:

Before I studied Aesthetic Realism, though I didn’t have trouble getting men to make a lot of me, my relationships didn’t succeed, and I felt so empty and loathing of myself. Then, in Aesthetic Realism consultations I learned that the purpose of love is to like the world through another person. I heard questions like the following: “The opposite of using a person to like the world is to use that person in some way to glorify oneself. What do you think you’ve loved more, Ms. McCluer—men, or your effect on them? Is the power you want the power to conquer a man or the power to see?”

A poem I love by Eli Siegel is humorously and deeply on this subject: “Is It Me, Darling, or Somebody Else, God Knows Who?—A Love Poem.” It’s about the desire—attained by the speaker in the poem—to have a man flatter and adore her above all else. In issue 987 of The Right of Aesthetic Realism to Be Known, Chairman of Education Ellen Reiss writes about the music of this poem:

It has the breathless triumph of a woman whom a man has made more important than the whole world. But Eli Siegel is the person who so mercifully understood the pain a woman feels even as she is triumphant—because she knows she has not shown her true self to the man, nor has she tried to see it. The sinking disappointment that accompanies her victory is in this poem’s music too, as the lines both eagerly swell and piteously droop.

Studying Aesthetic Realism has made it possible for me really to love a man, Kevin Fennell, my husband, and also to feel that it is I, the real me, who is being loved.

Is It Me, Darling, or Somebody Else,
God Knows Who?—A Love Poem

When you tell me that you never met anyone like me,

And that my blonde hair shines in the sun,

And that you’d rather see me than forty nephews,

And that an hour with me is triumph enough for a whole life,

And that when you talk with me you don’t know where you are you’re so happy,

And that you’d rather press my hand than be in a panel for a discussion of the world with learned professors,—

Darling, are you sure it’s me,

Or somebody else you’ve invented, God knows who—

Not me; just me?

Read more poems by Eli Siegel

Most Viewed Posts

  • The Philosophy of Depression

  • The Right of Aesthetic Realism to Be Known

  • “Alexander Calder: Art Answers the Questions of Our Lives”

  • Black & White: A Poem with Photographs

  • “Is Beauty the Making One of Opposites?”

  • “Books”—an Essay for Children

  • “A Good Husband: What Does That Mean?”

  • “Man and Nature in New York and Kansas”

  • “Hawthorne’s ‘The Man of Adamant’”

  • “The Beauty of Art & the Pain about Love”

  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Mission Statement
    • What Is Aesthetic Realism?
    • Eli Siegel, Founder
    • Faculty
    • Some Background
  • Calendar
  • How to Study
    Aesthetic Realism
    • Classes
      • The Aesthetic Realism Explanation of Poetry
      • Anthropology Is about You & Everyone
      • “If It Moves, It Can Move You”: Opposites in the Cinema
      • The Visual Arts & the Opposites
      • The Aesthetic Realism Teaching Method
      • The Opposites in Music
      • Understanding Marriage!
    • Consultations
      • What Happens in an Aesthetic Realism Consultation?
      • Aesthetic Realism Consultation of Nancy Huntting
      • Coldness, Warmth, & Mistakes by Jaime Torres, DPM
      • What Kind of Effect on Men? by Lauren Phillips
      • My Aesthetic Realism Consultations by Richita Anderson
      • The Fight about Excitement by Dan McClung
      • The Trouble with Competition by Miriam Weiss
    • Workshops for Educators
    • Outreach
      • Art Talks
      • Architecture
      • Bullying
      • Film Presentations
      • Seniors
      • Theatre Company
      • Young People
  • Events
    • Public Seminars
    • Theatrical & Musical Matinees
    • Saturday Night Presentations
    • Directions
  • Periodical
  • Library
    • Online Library
    • Films & Videos
    • Blog
    • Lectures
      • Aesthetic Realism and Love, Introduction
      • Aesthetic Realism and Love, Part 1
      • Aesthetic Realism and Love, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Expression, Introduction by Ellen Reiss
      • Aesthetic Realism and Expression, Part 1
      • Aesthetic Realism and Expression, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Hope
      • Aesthetic Realism and Hope, Part 2
      • The Drama of Mind, Introduction
      • The Drama of Mind, Part 1
      • The Drama of Mind, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Introduction
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Part 1
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Part 2
      • Aesthetic Realism and Learning, Part 3
      • Map to Happiness, by Eli Siegel
      • Greenwich Village Is in the World
      • Mind and Intelligence, Introduction by Ellen Reiss
      • Mind and Intelligence, by Eli Siegel, Part 1
      • Mind and Intelligence, by Eli Siegel, Part 2
      • Mind and Intelligence, by Eli Siegel, Part 3
      • Mind and Schools
      • Mind and Schools by Eli Siegel, Part 1
      • Mind and Schools by Eli Siegel, Part 2
      • Mind and Schools by Eli Siegel, Part 3
      • Aesthetic Realism and People
      • Aesthetic Realism and Education
      • So, What Is Bitterness?
    • News Archive
    • Related Resources
  • Book Store
  • Visual & Dramatic Arts
    • Terrain Gallery
    • Koppelman Foundation
    • Aesthetic Realism Theatre Company
  • En Español

To Contribute | Contact | En Español

Aesthetic Realism Foundation    141 Greene Street   New York, NY 10012   212.777.4490

Privacy Policy | Blog Comment Policy   Copyright © 1997–2025   Aesthetic Realism Foundation

To Contribute | Contact | En Español

Aesthetic Realism Foundation
141 Greene Street
New York, NY 10012
212.777.4490

Privacy Policy

Blog Comment Policy

Copyright © 1997–2025
Aesthetic Realism Foundation

MENU
  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Mission Statement
    • What Is Aesthetic Realism?
    • Eli Siegel, Founder
    • Faculty
    • Some Background
  • Calendar
  • How to Study
    Aesthetic Realism
    • Classes
    • Consultations
    • Workshops for Educators
    • Outreach
  • Events
    • Public Seminars
    • Theatrical & Musical Matinees
    • Saturday Night Presentations
    • Directions
  • Periodical
  • Library
    • Online Library
    • Films & Videos
    • Blog
    • Lectures
    • News Archive
    • Related Resources
  • Book Store
  • Visual & Dramatic Arts
    • Terrain Gallery
    • Koppelman Foundation
    • Aesthetic Realism Theatre Company
  • En Español
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
    • Directions
    • To Contribute
    • flat_facebook