New issue—
“Aristotle & Our Own Lives”
Number 2133.—April 10, 2024
Dear Unknown Friends:
Here is part 4 of the great 1972 lecture A Poem Is in the World, by Eli Siegel. In it he relates three huge things: 1) what an authentic poem is; 2) what those works called “the great books” have, making them worthy of the phrase; and 3) the structure of the world itself. These large matters, Aesthetic Realism shows, are not fancy things, existing in some territory apart from our daily lives, apart from our agitations, yearnings, thoughts about work and money and love. At the basis of the lecture is this Aesthetic Realism principle: “The world, art, and self explain each other: each is the aesthetic oneness of opposites.”
A Person, Centuries Ago
Thus far in the lecture, Mr. Siegel has been commenting on statements in Mortimer Adler’s How to Read a Book. And in the present section he begins discussing passages from a work about which Adler speaks a little. It is, says Mr. Siegel, “one of the great books, undoubtedly”: Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, written in the 4th century BCE.
Mr. Siegel loved Aristotle. That love is present even as he criticizes some of the Aristotelian statements he’s discussing. I am moved, for example, by these sentences of Mr. Siegel, so casual yet so exact, and, in their exactitude, tender:
But we are with Aristotle. And we have Aristotle trying to express his own feeling, as all writing does, and something about possible good in the world.
That Aristotle—the grand, classical, seemingly forbidding Aristotle—had human feeling which was his own, is not something generally thought of. There is warmth as Mr. Siegel speaks of it quietly, and places it simply with Aristotle’s saying “something about possible good in the world…. more
Recent issues—#2132 The World’s Opposites—in Books & Us | #2131 A Person, and the Wide World | #2130 How Do We Want to See?
A selection of previous issues on— Art | Literature | Men & Women | Economics | Racism | Education | Nat’l Ethics | Mind
Subscribe to The Right Of— Subscribe: Email | Subscribe: Print*
The Right Of is edited by Ellen Reiss, Aesthetic Realism Chairman of Education, who is author of its commentaries.
*The print edition is not currently available, due to the Covid-19 pandemic, but you can read the online edition, and “subscribe” without charge to emails that link you to each issue on its publication date.